In Mrs. Dalloway, by Virginia Woolf, as Peter Walch ponders life, a voice "interrupted him" (80). This voice "bubble[s]" up through the earth, spewing a message that is not human-- the sounds "ee um fah um so foo swee too eem oo" have no meaning. But they have all the meaning.
In "The Great Gig In The Sky", the beginning of the song features a quiet voice. Random words and thoughts can be heard over the piano intro. Then the song really begins. A voice soars over the man talking and begins a melody-- but with no words. Only moans and cries can be heard over the piano, drums, guitar, and bass. The sounds have no English meaning. But they have all the meaning.
The words of both examples mean something greater than language can give to them: they speak of a universal truth. Woolf's voice "stood singing of love-- love which lasted millions of years,"; this "ancient sound" exists because the universal meaning of love is not affected by time (81). Similar to Pink Floyd's rendition, no real words are needed. The emotions and meanings can be taken from the wailing sounds. Even the title of the song, with the inclusion of the words "in the sky" can help to determine the message. Something omnipresent, and greater-than-human is suggested.
But most of all, the sounds of the woman singing seem exactly how Virgina Woolf would have intended the voice in Mrs. Dalloway to be heard.
Jon/Jack,
ReplyDeleteWoah. This post is awesome. I think its so cool that you made the comparison between the song and the piece and even inserted that into your blog by repeating "The sounds have no English meaning. But they have all the meaning." Very cool, I like it.
Jack, I really love how you incorporated Pink Floyd in your blog. Isn't it crazy how random songs can connect so perfectly with what you are doing in AP English? (: I agree with Eric with the quote, it's like it was written for Mrs. Dalloway. Great job!
ReplyDeleteHi Jack, I think that it's really creative that you were able to Virginia Woolf to Pink Floyd. The comparison you make is really cool. And I agree with both Eric and Hannah!! It really does seem like it was written for the book lol.
ReplyDelete